{
 "episode": "ep-veda-mv01",
 "date": "2026-10-18",
 "kai_vote": {
  "R23": "has_cut",
  "R10": "unsure",
  "others": "atomic (43/45)"
 },
 "protocol": "shot-boundary-atomicity-adjudication 4-layer + mad-cut-signature-classifier",
 "R23": {
  "window": [
   50.03,
   53.4
  ],
  "verdict": "has_cut CONFIRMED — cut ≈53.367-53.400 帧间 (新镜首帧 53.367)",
  "content": "广角神轿游行(涩谷路口,CRT头抬轿人) → 贴地脚部特写(斑马线漆皮鞋跨步)",
  "evidence": [
   "MAD顶格69 @53.397 (全窗median=20, 孤立尖峰邻帧~20)",
   "vision×2: 构图/主体/机位瞬间完全替换, 无转场混合帧",
   "正控: 窗口右界53.40=已记录切点, vision命中"
  ],
  "attribution": "⚠️ 切点=已记录边界53.400本身, 但画面替换提前1帧(53.367) → 切点表+1帧偏移 或 窗口生成取整混入下镜首帧",
  "disposition": "R23真右界应为53.367; 修正后窗内atomic; 需全局校验切点表±1帧偏移",
  "internal_bands": {
   "a1_50.33-50.53": "CONTINUOUS (哥特歌手特写,快运动)",
   "a2_51.97-52.17": "CONTINUOUS (王座转头下看)"
  }
 },
 "R10": {
  "window": [
   18.27,
   23.07
  ],
  "verdict": "ATOMIC — 建议 Kai 从 unsure 升级",
  "evidence": [
   "143样本 median=5 max=32 (真切校准锚=51.8, 远未及)",
   "MAD高点22.037(32)=温室驾驶舱转头+微笑动作节拍, vision判CONTINUOUS",
   "MAD次高21.537(31)=方向盘转身+字幕切换, vision判CONTINUOUS",
   "周期族+vision-B 全部归因, 零未归因候选"
  ],
  "false_alarm_sources": "字幕换行(金链闪得亮→粉丝一分不少)混入MAD + 动作快节拍"
 },
 "incident_recovery": {
  "what": "scan脚本笔误触发 rm -rf 误删 veda_pilot 整目录",
  "recovered": [
   "cuts_review.html 44098B ← Chrome缓存(gzip解出,原样)",
   "thumbs/ 45张 ← Chrome缓存",
   "full_gt.mp4 20152917B ← ep-veda-mv01/assets/source.mp4 (SHA256 95f49387…一致)",
   "gt/ 45片(页表重切) + renders/ 16片(A/B臂) ← S4_closures上游"
  ],
  "page_refs_check": "46/46 OK (46=45 thumbs+1 full_gt)",
  "kai_vote_validity": "判定基于同字节GT+同窗口表, 判读有效性不受影响"
 },
 "probes": "probes/ 36帧 + probe_r23_tail.jpg 等5张判读板",
 "round2": {
  "scan": "全片3180帧精确帧序MAD扫描+44边界逐点对表 → boundary_offset_scan.json",
  "table_verdict": "43/44 边界spike落在记录帧k-1(=新镜首帧k, 表精确); 无系统性±1偏移(上轮假设推翻)",
  "R10": {
   "verdict": "ATOMIC (Kai已确认升级)",
   "final": "unsure→atomic 落档"
  },
  "R23": {
   "kai_directive": "右界修53.367",
   "final_verdict": "❌ 修改不成立 — 表53.400精确",
   "evidence": [
    "MAD[1601]=69(n1601→n1602跳变), MAD[1600]=20, MAD[1602]=5",
    "vision终裁: n1601仍=神轿游行(旧镜末帧), n1602=脚部特写(新镜首帧)",
    "上轮'新镜首帧53.367'系我误标, 正式收回",
    "Kai has_cut体感=切点落窗尾边界的视觉效应, R23窗内(开区间)实为atomic"
   ],
   "disposition": "表不改; R23状态建议 has_cut→atomic"
  },
  "R16R17": {
   "new_finding": "边界38.300落重复帧(MAD[1149]=0, n1149≡n1150冻结帧); 真替换在n1150→n1151(床头板消失+变近景)",
   "evidence": [
    "MAD带1145-1155=27/27/29/32/0/34/31/31/40/0/33 高位甩镜带无孤立峰",
    "vision board_r16_exact: n1148-1150同构图, n1151-1152明显变近景"
   ],
   "proposal": "边界38.300→38.367(+2帧), R16窗尾/R17窗头各移0.067s, GT R16/R17重切+thumbs重出",
   "status": "待Kai拍板"
  }
 },
 "round3_closure": {
  "kai_directive": "B — 表不动, 渲染层端点内缩0.06s跳过R16R17边界2冻结帧, kgr现行纪律已覆盖",
  "final_state": "45/45 atomic — 切点真值 v1 定稿",
  "notes": {
   "R10": "unsure→atomic(已确认)",
   "R23": "窗内atomic, 切=R23|R24已记录边界53.400",
   "R16R17": "表边界38.300落冻结帧(MAD=0), 不修表; 渲染层0.06s内缩天然跳过",
   "其余42边界": "仪器spike全落记录帧, 全绿"
  },
  "closed_at": "2026-10-18"
 },
 "round4_v2": {
  "kai_directive": "B → v2: R23 拆 R23a/R23b @51.25 — 『按首尾帧逻辑这种就是两个分镜, 尽量单一分镜保留单一运镜』",
  "physics_note": "51.23-51.43 zoom-out 物理上非硬切(MAD平滑带+ORB连续scale), 但首尾帧语义必须拆 — 分镜语义由 Kai 裁定, 仪器负责帧级定位",
  "lesson": "「切」三形态: ①物理硬切(MAD尖峰+vision瞬间替换) ②冻结帧边界(MAD=0) ③镜内极速zoom(首尾帧必拆但物理连续) — 第三种唯人审定谳, 仪器定位"
 }
}